The Carat Standard

GIA report 2235087184

5.00 ct Round Brilliant Diamond

75/100 · Considered

A balanced profile with a few questions to carry forward.

What reads well

  • D color is in the colorless range.
  • VVS1 clarity: inclusions are not a practical visual factor.
  • No fluorescence: no haze risk to weigh.

What deserves a closer look

  • The GIA cut grade is Good: the lab's own assessment points to less brightness and fire than its top tier.
  • Crown 37.5° / pavilion 40.8° fall outside the pairing zone associated with strong light return.
  • Depth 65.7% sits outside the preferred round range.
  • Very thick girdle: a thick girdle carries hidden weight and can reduce face-up size.
  • The diameter is small for 5.00 ct: weight is carried below the girdle rather than face-up.

The reading, field by field

Table · Ideal
At 59%, the table sits within the typical 53–59% range for a round brilliant, balancing brightness with fire.
Total depth · Closer look
65.7% is deeper than typical for a round brilliant (59.5–63%). Extra depth holds weight below the girdle, so the stone can face up smaller than its carat weight suggests.
Crown angle · Closer look
A 37.5° crown is steeper than the typical 32–36° zone. Steep crowns can add fire, but only pair well with a slightly shallower pavilion.
Pavilion angle · Ideal
40.8° is inside the narrow 40.5–41.3° zone where the pavilion returns light most efficiently.
Polish · Ideal
Excellent polish is the top finish grade — facets are cleanly executed with nothing that would soften sparkle.
Symmetry · Favorable
Very Good symmetry is a fine result; the difference from Excellent is rarely visible without magnification.
Girdle · Closer look
Very thick, faceted, 6.5%: a thick girdle carries weight in the rim, so the stone can face up a little smaller for its carat weight. It is durable, though.
Culet · Ideal
None: no visible culet facet when viewed face-up.
Color · Ideal
D is in the colorless range and faces up white in any metal.
Clarity · Ideal
VVS1: inclusions, if any, are only visible under magnification.
Fluorescence · Ideal
None: no meaningful effect on appearance.
Cut grade · Closer look
Good as issued by GIA, on GIA's own scale. The measured proportions above tell you more than the label.

What to check on the exact stone

  • Does the steep crown give lively fire without making the center look darker?
  • With 65.7% depth, does this stone face up smaller than a typical 5.00 ct round?
  • Does the feather reach the outer edge where a setting prong could put pressure on it?
  • Can you show me the inscribed report number under a loupe before it is set?

Report facts

Origin
Natural
Carat
5.00 ct
Shape
Round Brilliant
Cut grade
Good (GIA)
Color
D
Clarity
VVS1
Measurements
10.36–10.53 × 6.86 mm
Table
59%
Total depth
65.7%
Crown angle
37.5°
Pavilion angle
40.8°
Polish
Excellent
Symmetry
Very Good
Girdle
Very thick, faceted, 6.5%
Culet
None
Fluorescence
None

About The Carat Standard Score

How The Carat Standard reads a report